Evan McGarrity is a sophomore at Milton University in Western New York. Tired of one-night stands, he's looking for honest love and someone to share his life with. When he meets Sebastian Tantalos, his life unexpectedly takes a turn for the better. The new romance is everything Evan has hoped for: Sebastian is funny, intelligent, exciting, articulate, and handsome as hell. Just as Evan realizes he's starting to fall in love with Sebastian, trouble in the form of Sebastian's old boyfriend, Brent, rears its ugly head. Brent is determined to win Sebastian back, no matter the cost and by any means necessary. As Brent begins to weave his web of hatred and deceit, Evan starts to doubt Sebastian's love for him. When Evan turns to his old flame for comfort, the relationship is torn apart. Can these two men find their way back to each other and salvage their love?